The Simon Institute for Longterm Governance (SI) aims to increase the long-term impact of policymaking processes.
In its first 24 months, from March 15th, 2021 to March 15th, 2023, SI’s core objectives are to
- prove its approach by generating early signs of counterfactual impact;
- narrow down its focus until 2026; and
- raise funding to employ at least 5 full-time equivalents (FTE). [EDIT 2021-09-14: after consulting with advisers, we have decided not to hire additional staff until at least March 2022 to collect more data to prove our concept]
In 2021, SI will
- deploy three training programs for policymakers to deal with complexity;
- publish 5 foundational working papers and 1 peer-reviewed article;
- raise between CHF 200’000 and 2’000’000; and
- set up its legal and operating structure.
The public launch is set to complete on March 31st, 2021. SI will be a Swiss association with recognized non-profit status.
We will deploy our training programs in partnership with the Geneva Science-Policy Interface and plan to deliver each program four times to different policy audiences to test their fit.
We will summarize our foundational research in a series of working papers on ‘Longterm Governance’, spelling out our approach for fostering resilience to global catastrophic risks by supporting coordination in international policy networks.
This post delineates SI’s action plan. We hope it will provide a clear understanding of where SI is heading in the upcoming months.
We encourage you to share feedback, ideas, and collaboration opportunities.
In the next 24 months (2021-2022), SI enters its first phase of development. At the end of 2022, SI’s governing board and staff will evaluate progress. We will continue operating only if the goals below are achieved. Baselines and exact targets will be established at the end of 2021.
We will define a detailed plan for 2022 in Q4 of 2021. We currently expect to consolidate SI’s projects, positioning, and operations, raise further funding and develop a post-2022 plan, including a shut-down option.
After at most 1.5 years of work, via surveys and case studies, we expect to see:
- Policymakers use insights and tools from our trainings in their work;
- Policymakers better understand global catastrophic risks and longtermism;
- Longtermists better understand international policymaking;
- Individuals improve their career plans;
- Our research can pass academic peer-review.
- 1.1.1 Test table-top exercise on pandemic preparedness (Q3&4)
- 1.1.2 Test workshop on behavioral insights for complex problem solving (Q2&3)
- 1.1.3 Test training on multi-objective prioritization in policymaking (Q4)
- 1.2.1 Publish working paper on “policymaking for the long-term future” (Q2)
- 1.2.2 Publish method paper on “computational policy process studies” (Q2)
- 1.2.3 Publish “needs analysis for complex problem-solving in international policy networks” (Q2)
- 1.2.4 Publish working paper on “dynamics of policy change and their implications for long-term policymaking” (Q3)
- 1.2.5 Publish working paper on “strategies for effective longtermist advocacy” (Q3)
- 1.2.6 Publish “review of leverage points to strengthen individual decision-making in the face of complexity” (Q3)
- 1.2.7 Submit funding proposal on “computational policy process studies” to Swiss National Science Foundation (Q3)
- 1.2.8 Publish working paper on “strengthening policy processes for the longterm future” (Q4)
- 1.2.9 Publish “an agenda for research and practice in longterm governance” (Q4)
- 2.1 Fundraise minimum CHF 113k by Q3 and push for up to CHF 2m in Q4
- 2.2 Recruit 1 additional full-time equivalent of priority roles as soon as 2 years of salary can be guaranteed (~200’000 CHF) [EDIT 2021-09-14: after consulting with advisers, we have decided not to hire additional staff until at least March 2022 to collect more data to prove our concept]
- 2.3 Build up a good reputation among target audience (events rated ≥8/10)
- 3.1 Launch website and public announcement in Q1
- 3.2 Build SI’s legal foundation in Q1
- 3.3 Design management and operations systems throughout Q1-3
The rationale for SI’s decision-making support tools is to test the contextual validity of the evidence used to back its theory of change. Direct engagement with policy networks allows gathering real-world feedback to refine strategy and ensure value add. Publishing our foundational research allows others to scrutinize and build on our work.
We aim to
- Refine our understanding of what constitutes counterfactually valuable decision-making support in international policy networks;
- Identify longterm-focused individuals and organizations to build a strong network advocating for future generations;
- Motivate further research and experimentation on strengthening policy processes for the longterm future.
We will test our training programs at a small scale in high-bandwidth communication settings to maintain the ability to correct mistakes until we have gathered evidence of positive impact and formalized models of mechanisms at play. Only after we have gained confidence in the generalizability of our insights will we consider developing e.g. online content or train-the-trainers programs.
We hope to be able to draw preliminary conclusions after iterative testing throughout our first year of operations. In the second year, we currently expect to integrate separate workshops into one coherent program that we run at regular intervals and in official partnership with key institutions. We will also support the GSPI in reappropriating our content to its audiences beyond the governance of global catastrophic risks.
Next to training, we will wrap up the research that has led to SI’s conception to then fully focus refining our training programs. We will publish a series of working papers underpinning our strategy and reviews that lead to our current offer of decision-making support tools. Further, we will submit a grant proposal on computational policy process studies in Q3 2021 to test whether there is potential to couple empirical and computational research efforts by Q2 2022, or whether we should continue to focus on practical decision-making support for longer.
In 2021, the goal is to fundraise in order to scale up operations in 2022.
To maintain capacity throughout 2022, SI requires to fundraise at least CHF 113’000. However, this is unlikely to be sufficient to reach our 2-year development goals and would merely enable Konrad and Max to pivot.
[EDIT 2021-09-14: after consulting with advisers, we have decided not to hire additional staff until at least March 2022 to collect more data to prove our concept]
To scale at capacity and build runway, we currently expect to be able to make use of as much as CHF 2’000’000 in the first 2-years of operations. This would allow us to hire an additional 5 full-time equivalents (FTE) and thereby drastically increase our capacity to run workshops, collect and analyze data, improve our strategy and support the translation of longtermist ideas into policy practices.
Our first hires will bring additional experience in:
- Training: designing and facilitating workshops.
- Development: fundraising, grant writing, relationship management, financial reporting and public relations.
- Operations: event planning, management and organizational administration.
- Research: computational social science, experimental design, data analysis, impact evaluation.
For full-time positions, we are looking for individuals with 5+ years of experience in international policy networks. We will publicly advertise openings and institute a recruitment process consisting of (i) application, (ii) a work test, (iii) two interviews, and (iv) a paid 2-week work trial. We are developing an intense onboarding process to empower co-founder-equivalent first employees who have the agency and knowledge to effectively advance SI’s mission.
To raise funding, we will continuously dedicate a certain share of our available resources to fundraising. We expect this to be about 20% in the first two years and reduce to maybe 10% after two years, once SI has proven its raison d’être.
We will start by leveraging personal connections to various grantmaking institutions for general support. Once these discussions are set in motion, we will submit grant proposals for general support to various foundations that seem aligned with our values. We expect this to take up most of our fundraising capacity until late 2021. Only then will we start submitting project-specific proposals to large grant-making institutions.
We plan to build our reputation along the following dimensions:
- Expertise in the field of longterm governance
- Expertise in the field of decision-making support
- Valuable new actor in International Geneva
The reputation above will result mainly from the smooth execution of our decision-making support and research publication. In addition, we plan to speak at events and engage with the media selectively.
To maintain relationships with our audience, we will irregularly update our website, publish newsletter updates, frequently share news on LinkedIn and Twitter, and engage intensely with our closest network via Zulip and Email.
Our goal is for SI to be an independently operating entity by the start of Q3 2021. The legal institution of SI consists of the constitutive assembly, application for nonprofit status and official registration. The public launch of SI has two phases: publishing the website and an announcement on the EA forum. The operational launch entails opening bank accounts and arranging fiscal sponsorship for donors from abroad.
In Q2, we will define our organizational structure. We will formalize the individual affiliation of board members, advisers and collaborators. Further, we will finalize our recruiting process, including the development of work tests; develop our onboarding process; and set up our operations infrastructure for accounting, monitoring, evaluation and learning.
As a result of a pre-mortem, we have identified three main threats to our current plans:
- Failing to deliver proof of concept due to inability to run in-person events
- First publications do not seem of practical relevance or sufficient quality
- Fundraising via the longtermist network is unsuccessful due to inferential gaps
We plan to mitigate these threats as follows:
- If in-person events are impossible, we will pivot to (1) online services (coaching, consulting) and/or (2) focus on research.
- Conditional on funding, our second hire focuses on methods for data collection, analysis and scientific writing. Otherwise, we focus on decision-making support to deliver proof of concept.
- If we do not receive seed funding from the longtermist community, we will focus on establishing SI within the Genevan ecosystem first.
To adapt systematically and avoid losing momentum, we use the following mechanisms:
- Monitoring-Evaluation-Learning: we track the time allocated to each of our three main annual goals, track milestones and their required time estimates. We survey our audience and assess feedback on tools and research to constantly refine our approach. We write learning reports for each project after the pilot phase.
- Quarterly strategic meeting: staff revisits the annual plan and adapts the project schedule as a function of progress to design a detailed plan for each quarter.
- Semiannual board meeting: in February and October, the governing board discusses progress and adapts the strategy accordingly.